Product Reviews

The following reviews will are all based on my personal experience of the product. I hope you find them useful


Bushnell 8x42 'Birding Series' Binoculars



I bought Belinda a pair of these bins for £129 in Cley Spy in March 2016 ready for our trip to Borneo. Having tried out a Minox pair and a Hawke pair which were around the £100 mark these knocked the spots of both those on optical performance. The advantage of Cley Spy is being able to try optics out in their garden and even in very dull murky conditions the image with these bins was clear and bright. The focus was much easier than the others as it's not so critical (i.e. you can  achieve focus even if you're a mm or two out with the focussing wheel). Close focus was impressive too with them focussing down to c2 meters. There is a very small amount of vignetting around the edge of the image but for bins of this price it is completely acceptable. The only downside with them is the size, although they are not too heavy they are quite 'long', purely a cosmetic thing I know but on the whole you get a lot for your money with these nice bins. Ideal for a beginner birder or even for a 2nd pair for the car.
Belinda christened them with a look at Lapland Buntings at Blakeney!


 

The Birds of Western Africa (2nd edition)


I bought this book in December 2014. Having arranged a trip to the Gambia in January I set about looking to see if I should update my id guide for the area prior to the trip. I have previously used the Helm guide Birds of The Gambia and Senegal (Clive Barlow and Tim Wacher) so the obvious choice for an update seemed to be the new Helm guide Birds of Senegal and The Gambia (Nik Borrow and Ron Demey). It seems that this is however just an extract from Birds of West Africa by the same authors and with the latter cheaper to buy on Amazon it seemed a no-brainer so I went ahead and bought it.
And I have to say it is rather disappointing. Text on each species is limited to a paragraph or two which is perhaps understandable to keep the book of manageable 'field guide' size but what really lets the book down is the quality of the plates which are a step backwards bearing in mind some of the superbly illustrated guides there are ut there these days. The plates are very diagramatical with black and red species such as the Bluebills on plate 250 seeming to have suffered particularly badly. Possibly something to do with the printing process? Plate 117, Bee-eaters has to be one of the worst plates I've seen for some while. Some are better than others though and in general the raptors fare pretty well. Text and distribution maps for each species are shown opposite the plates which is a layout that is user-friendly and one I like.
For about £21 I perhaps shouldn't complain too much and it's certainly got to be a better buy that the new Senegal/Gambia guide which is more expensive and just a subset of this book. In short, my copy won't be coming with me to the Gambia next month, I will stick with my old guide and the far superior illustrations in Birds of Africa, South of the Sahara which is reviewed further down this same page.            



Rare Birds of North America




I received a copy of this excelent book for my birthday in May 2014. With the title I had my reservations about how useful this might be for an Old World birder but I couldn't have been more wrong. The species covered include many of our common species, WP vagrants and south and central American vagrants and as I've birded in these regions I've found it very interesting and informative. The chapter on migration and vagrancy in birds introduces some fascinating concepts.
Needless to say the plates are superb. I've shown a couple above to give the reader an idea of their sheer quality and accuracy.
I'd urge any birder from this side of the pond who has an interest of bird vagrancy to grab themselves a copy of this book that can double up as reference material but also looks great as a coffee table tome.

Birds of Kuwait - book review (click link for the review)

Christmas 2011 Book suggestions - 6 books (click link for the review)

Birds of Africa, South of the Sahara (2nd edition)


I bought this book at the Birdfair back in August based on the fact that 'it'll come in handy one day' and was glad I did. The visual appeal is immediately obvious as soon as you open the book as the illustrations are very good indeed. Based on the species I know well I'd say they are accurate as well as being well presented (between 4 & 7 species per page with sexes, colour morphs and other plumages shown where appropriate). Each page is laid out very well with lines between species illustrations which I've found missing in many guides.
To cover such a vast area in one book is a monumental task and the resulting book is necessarily a bit too big to take out into the field. With birding trips very unlikely to encompass the whole region anyway this isn't a problem as the birder would take a more specific guide out with them.
The one criticism I'd make with the book is that no attempt is made in the range maps to differentiate between breeding and wintering ranges or to shown areas where a species can be expected on passage. To be fair this is explained in the range maps section and is only a minor point.
All in all it's well at least a 9 out of 10 and is one of the best illustrated field guides I've seen yet.
At under £20 on Amazon at the time of writing it would be a shame not to buy this marvellous book!

No comments:

Post a Comment